Senate leader John Burton, in a memo to members, has put them on notice to be ready to meet in special session on the afternoon of Nov. 18, the day after Arnold Schwarzenegger is scheduled to be sworn in as governor.
Posted by dweintraub at 3:33 PM
--Gov. Gray Davis and federal lawmakers from California asked for federal financial help in thinning dead trees in April, citing the danger of catastrophic fire. The feds failed to respond to the plea until last Friday, then denied the request. In the Chronicle.
--In the same story, its noted that forest scientists warned that more thinning was needed years ago, but were stymied by environmentalists opposed to legislation that would have allowed it. They opposed the proposals because the bills would have also allowed timber companies to cut more healthy trees.
--The San Diego County sheriffs pilots who rescued the hunter believed to have started the Cedar fire alerted the US Forest Service, asked them to help fight the fire and asked for permission to collect water from hanging buckets to try to douse it. The Forest Service told them to stand down because night was falling and choppers dont fight fire at night. Story in the LA Times.
--And here is the SD Union story from Thursday about teh state's refusal to use federal helicopters from North Island.
The debate over thinning and who did what, when, is going to rage for months, if not years. But it should be noted that most of the damage so far has occurred far from the forests that are at issue. The chaparral that burned in Ramona, Alpine, Crest, the city of San Diego and the Simi Valley has never been a serious candidate for the kind of thinning contemplated in the Healthy Forest bill, nor would it be practical to include it.
Then there is the story of John Lucas, the former firefighter who fought alone to save his own house near Lake Arrowhead. What Lucas did when the fire arrived couldn't be matched by most people. But it's interesting to note what he did in advance: planted a mini-greenbelt, thinned the forest, built a water tower. He knew the fire was coming and prepared for it, and his home survived. An example for other individuals in fire-prone areas, as well as for the government. In the Bee.
Posted by dweintraub at 12:48 PM
Ted Costa and Peoples Advocate, sponsors of the Davis Recall, today unveiled a proposed ballot measure to change the way political district lines are drawn. Costa's plan would allow legislative leaders to appoint 20 Californians to a pool from which the Judicial Council would select three special masters to make the decision. The masters would choose a plan from among those submitted by lawmakers and citizens groups. The choice would then go back to the Legislature for ratification and, finally, to a vote of the people. Costa hopes to qualify the measure for the November, 2004 ballot. If approved by the voters, the plan would take effect immediately, meaning that new districts would go into effect for the 2006 elections, even as voters had before them the question of whether they approve of those districts.
Posted by dweintraub at 1:42 PM
David Drucker at the Daily Bulletin in this story spots a point I overlooked in Legislative Analyst Liz Hill's budget analysis: she restates and clarifies her longheld position that Davis overstated the size of the shortfall. It was never $38 billion, Hill says, but more like $30 billion. The difference was in spending, not required by law, that Davis would have wanted to do but couldn't because of tough times. The guv listed those priorities, said we couldn't do them and then counted them as budget cuts, inflating both the size of the problem and the portion of his solution that came from spending reductions rather than tax increases. Hill does agree with the Davis folks that the current operating shortfall remains in the $10 billion range.
Posted by dweintraub at 9:03 AM
Rob Reiner and the California Teachers Association are preparing to file a ballot measure for November, 2004 that would increase commercial property taxes by 55 percent and dedicate the money -- $4.5 billion annually -- to expanded pre-school and K-12 education. The money for K-12 would have to supplement, not supplant, current funding and could be used only for reducing class size, purchasing textbooks, instructional materials, supplies and equipment, training teachers or raising teacher salaries. The pre-school money would be dedicated to universal access for all children in the year before kindergarten. That money could go for public preschool only. The measure would raise the property tax rate from 1 percent to 1.55 percent on commercial property, with agricultural, timber, open space and government property exempted. Rental property assessed at less than $700,000 would be exempt, and the rate on property assessed at above that amount would rise to the new limit on a sliding scale.
Posted by dweintraub at 1:56 PM
More, this one from the LA Times, on the dispute over how quickly state and federal agencies moved to combat the San Diego fire.
Posted by dweintraub at 7:08 AM
Former congressman and California Atty. Gen. Dan Lungren has formally opened his campaign for the 3rd District congressional seat now held by Doug Ose, who is retiring. Lungren will face off against state Sen. Rico Oller in the Republican primary in March. Lungren is backed by, among others, Ted Costa, the official sponsor of the California recall.
Posted by dweintraub at 2:59 PM
Dick Riordan is rumored to be a possible choice as education secretary for Schwarzenegger. It could be a brilliant move, placing LAs former reform-minded mayor, who did battle with the teachers unions to try to turn the citys schools around, as the new governors point man on public education. But heres an even smarter idea: kill the job. In California, the education secretary is a glorified adviser to the governor with few real duties and only a handful of education programs to administer. We already have an entire department full of bureaucrats run by an elected superintendent (Jack OConnell). And we have a policy-setting state board of education whose members are appointed by the governor. The job of education secretary was created by Pete Wilson in 1991 to prove that he was a pro-schools Republican and to give him more bodies in the battle against the bureaucracy. The office has grown steadily since then, even as its authority remains fairly limited. Ideally, Id like to junk the superintendent and the state board and vest administrative powers in the governor, just as we do for health care, welfare, environmental regulation and other big issues. Then, maybe, we would need an education secretary instead of the superintendent. But that isnt going to happen any time soon. In the meantime, Schwarzenegger could demonstrate his commitment to smaller government by naming Riordan or someone else as his education adviser, housed in the governors office, and eliminating the rest of the office of the education secretary. The move would save only about $1 million and would be criticized by status-quoists who equate government departments with concern about an issue. But it would be a gutsy step showing that the new gov is not wedded to the old way of doing things.
Posted by dweintraub at 9:16 AM
Mickey Kaus makes the case against editing blogs.
Posted by dweintraub at 9:02 AM
Josh Marshall at Talking Points Memo asked for contributions from readers to send him to New Hampshire to cover the final ten days of the presidential primary campaign. In 24 hours, he raised more than enough to cover the trip, and now he is offering refunds to donors. Love it.
Posted by dweintraub at 8:02 AM
From the Chronicle: "Gov. Gray Davis has warned Gov.-elect Arnold Schwarzenegger that California's unemployment insurance system will go bankrupt only weeks after he takes office, forcing the state to seek its first-ever bailout loan from the federal government that could top $1.17 billion."
Read the whole thing here.
In March, 2002, I wrote a column that warned of the coming bankruptcy in the fund. You can download it here.
Posted by dweintraub at 7:30 AM
Republicans on Monday accused Gov. Gray Davis of dragging his feet before requesting military help to fight the fires in San Diego County. Davis denies it. The San Diego Union provides this detailed story explaining how federal law and bureaucracy make quick decisions difficult in situations like this. Among other things, a 1930s-era law designed to protect civilian jobs prohibits the U.S. Forest Service from requesting military planes until all of its own resources are exhausted. The story does suggest that Davis, a former Army captain, might have been guilty of sticking to the established chain of command. Rep. Duncan Hunter, chairman of the House Armed Services Committee, said he gave state officials the home number of the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, who was standing by to order two planes into action, but nobody ever called him for help. Hunter's Alpine home was believed to be among those destroyed in the fire.
Posted by dweintraub at 6:12 AM
Public relations exec Donna Lucas has joined the Schwarzenegger transition staff as an aide to Maria Shriver. Lucas, a partner in the Porter Novelli International PR firm, is taking a three-week leave from the company to work as a volunteer on the transition staff, where she will help Shriver set up her own staff and establish the priorities on which she will concentrate as First Lady. Lucas was a press aide to former Gov. George Deukmejian and press secretary for George Bush's 1988 presidential campaign in California (the last Republican to win the state) before building a successful Sacramento public relations firm that eventually was bought by Porter Novelli. She is married to San Francisco Chronicle reporter Greg Lucas.
Posted by dweintraub at 4:47 PM
Democrat state Sen. Dean Florez, who as chairman of the Joint Legislative Audit Committee helped disclose the details behind the Oracle computer software foul-up, is working with Gov.-elect Arnold Schwarzenegger to find more waste and abuse in the state budget. Florez, never shy about publicity, tells me Schwarzenegger called him at home last week, and they spoke about the Oracle deal and the possibility of finding more problems deep within the state bureaucracy. Florez followed up with a short conversation with Schwarzenegger’s auditor, Donna Arduin, and the two plan to meet on Tuesday. Florez also has sent Schwarzenegger a six-page letter urging him to look at state overtime abuses, procurement practices, technology purchases, surplus property, and the Departments of Veterans Affairs and Corrections. The senator, who fell out of favor with Gray Davis after harshly criticizing his fellow Democrat over the Oracle debacle, told the new governor he could probably save at least $1 billion by following the Florez roadmap.
Posted by dweintraub at 4:21 PM
While the governor-elect is waiting for Florida budget chief Donna Arduin to complete her audit of California's books, he might want to review Legislative Analyst Elizabeth Hill's latest 77-page take on the budget, the shortfall, how we got here and what the outlook is for 04-05. You can find it here.
Posted by dweintraub at 3:38 PM
The Fresno Bee, the Chronicle and the Times take looks at Schwarzenegger's planned trip to Washington this week, and almost nobody in any of the three pieces believes the new governor can extract significant fiscal help from the federal government.
Posted by dweintraub at 8:51 AM
The Oakland Tribune takes a long, nuanced look at the controversy over UC Berkeley's admission of students with low SAT scores. The story adds new data about the race and ethnicity of the special admissions.
Posted by dweintraub at 8:28 AM
Here is the Bee's story on the appointments flap. It looks as if about 20 of the Davis appointees might survive. I think the untold angle in this whole afffair was that Senate Leader John Burton really did not want to bring his members back to do Davis' bidding, not just because it would look bad politically but because Burton never liked Davis. He's also not all that fond of some of the appointees. But he did want to protect Democratic interests on some of the board and commissions, especially the Agricultural Labor Relations Board, so the deal makes sense for both sides.
Posted by dweintraub at 8:06 AM
Senate Leader John Burton has notified members not to expect to reconvene in session before Gov. Gray Davis leaves office. That means last-minute Davis appointees who require confirmation will have their fates in the hands of Gov.-elect Schwarzenegger, who could rescind any of the appointments before they are confirmed.
This doesn't necessarily mean there is not a deal between the camps. We won't know that until we see how the new guv handles the old guv's moves. It is possible that Schwarzenegger has agreed to leave certain of Davis' appointments in place in exchange for an agreement that the Senate will not confirm the others.
Here is the text of Burton's notice to members:
"To quell any speculation regarding our reconvening in the near future: the Senate will not meet next week, nor at this time do I anticipate any extraordinary meeting.
"Legislative matters, including confirmation, will be handled in the normal course of business when we meet as regularly scheduled."
Posted by dweintraub at 4:22 PM
A coalition of business groups will seek to qualify a referendum to block the enactment of SB 2, the measure passed at the end of the legislative session to require businesses with more than 50 employees to provide health insurance for their workers. Calling themselves "Californians Against Government Run Healthcare," the California Chamber of Commerce, California Restaurant Association, California Taxpayers Association, California Retailers Association and the California Business Properties Association will try to round up 373,816 signatures of registered voters to put the bill on the March, 2004 ballot. The group claims the bill will cost business and consumers $7 billion a year and do for health care what the 1996 electricity industry restructuring bill did for California's energy industry.
This is at least the fourth move afoot to block actions taken by Gov. Gray Davis in the months before the recall. Sen. Tom McClintock is leading an effort to repeal the car tax, which Davis tripled by administrative order. Another group is trying to referenda SB 60, the measure that would allow illegal immigrants to obtain California drivers licenses. And religious conservatives are suing to block AB 205, which gave same-sex domestic partners many of the same rights and responsiblities now enjoyed by married couples.
Posted by dweintraub at 3:45 PM
State Sen. John Vasconcellos, who called Schwarzenegger a "boob" shortly after the election and said he was thinking of quitting the Legislature after 37 years rather than serve under him as governor, issued a long, rambling statement today retracting the words if not the sentiment. Vasco, in the 2,000-word piece, said he might have been wiser to use the word "amatuer" or "impersonator" or the "Grand Illusionist" rather than "boob," and he said he fully intended to serve the remainder of his term in the Legislature.
Said Vasco: "I have devoted 38 years of my life (more than 1/2 my life, 3/4s of my adult life) to serving the People and State of California, and to developing the masteries of subject and process that have enabled me to become a good effective trusted respected public servant; If I had announced last week that I fully intend to take over management of the New York Yankees for their coming World Series face-off, I'd expect most folks would have laughed out loud, and I
wouldn't have been surprised nor taken offense if any of them characterized me as in that outburst I did our Governor-elect."
Posted by dweintraub at 3:27 PM
Everybody made nice today when the governor and the governor-elect got together for their first meeting ever, to discuss the transition. But behind the scenes, the Davis and Schwarzenegger camps and the offices of Senate Leader John Burton are waging a three-way stare-down over potential last-minute Davis appointments that would need confirmation from the Senate if they are to stand. Schwarzenegger has said that he recognizes Davis's right to make appointments up until he leaves office. Davis has said he intends to exercise that right, and insiders believe the beneficiaries would include several of his top aides, including Chief of Staff Lynn Schenk and Cabinet Secretary Daniel Zingale. But some of the appointments the best and highest paying among them require Senate confirmation, and Burton is trying to decide whether to bring the body in for an unusual October session to do the deed. Democrats who favor doing so are relying on the legalistic view they have the right but perhaps ignoring the political realities. If Schwarzenegger objects, he can wage a public protest, and the reaction to the Senate's action would likely be highly negative. Most voters, even some of those who opposed the recall, would probably reject the idea of the ousted governor giving big jobs to his friends and aides on the way out the door, and to the Senate making a special effort to come in to help him cement those appointments in place. But Schwarzenegger also has something to gain from negotiating with Davis and Burton because Davis, if everybody agrees, could hold back on some appointments he is entitled to make and leave those slots for Schwarzenegger to fill when he takes office. That sort of deal would be typical. Davis and his predecessor, Pete Wilson, struck a pact along those lines in 1998. It would be, to use one of Schwarzenegger's favorite phrases, politics as usual.
For more on this topic, here is a Chronicle story on the subject.
Posted by dweintraub at 9:16 PM
"Where government moves in, community retreats, civil society disintegrates, and our ability to control our destiny atrophies. The result is: families under siege, war in the streets, unapologetic expropriation of property, the precipitous decline of the rule of law, the rapid rise of corruption, the loss of civility and the triumph of deceit," -- California Supreme Court Justice Janice Rogers Brown in a speech to the Federalist Society at the University of Chicago Law School three years ago.
Brown explained her views Wednesday at her comfirmation hearing for a seat on the Washington D.C. Circuit of the U.S. Court of Appeals. Here is the story in the Bee.
Posted by dweintraub at 6:41 AM
Gov.-elect Schwarzenegger says he will call the Legislature immediately into special session upon his swearing in, and will ask lawmakers to fix workers compensation, repeal SB 60, the illegal immigrant driver’s license bill, and begin work on closing the budget gap. Asked by reporters if maybe he was moving a little bit too quickly, Schwarzenegger replied:
"Action, action, action, action. That's what people have voted me into this office for. They wanted to have a governor that is filled with action, that performs and that represents the people, and that's what I'm here to do."
Here is the full story In the Bee.
Posted by dweintraub at 6:29 AM
While Gov.-elect Arnold Schwarzenegger was drawing the media throngs in the Capitol today, his transition director, Rep. David Dreier, slipped away for a private meeting with Sen. Tom McClintock. The session, which lasted about 30 minutes in McClintock's third-floor Capitol office, was the first serious outreach from the Schwarzenegger operation to the man many Republican insiders at one time thought might cost Arnold the election. I asked Dreier if the Schwarzenegger team planned to work with McClintock, and he suggested that his presence at the senator's office was an indication that they would. McClintock told me afterword that the meeting was "cordial" and said he stands ready to help Schwarzenegger on the goal they share: reining in state spending and cutting taxes. Typical in a situation like this would be for Schwarzenegger to freeze McClintock out, to marginalize him and try to make an example of a guy who was not a "team player." While I doubt the relations between the two will ever be warm, perhaps today's meeting was a sign that Schwarzenegger understands that one of the best ways to neutralize your enemies is to bring them into your fold.
Posted by dweintraub at 7:01 PM
The choice of Patricia Clarey as chief of staff leaves Arnold Schwarzenegger open to two quick criticisms: he is hiring, effectively, an HMO lobbyist as his top aide and also choosing a loyalist to former Gov. Pete Wilson. The lobbyist tag is obvious. Seems like a strange move for a guy who campaigned to sweep the special interests outta town. The Wilson connection is more subtle, in that Schwarzenegger does not want to be known as Pete Wilson's third term, but rather as his own man, running his own show. But Clarey has what Schwarzenegger needs. She knows the Capitol, knows the system, and she is smart, tough and organized. She was the "bad cop" to Bob White's "good cop" when she served as White deputy chief of staff under Wilson. White was schmoozer, the man about town, the governor's alter ego. He stayed above the fray except when his intervention was required, and when it was, he wasn't beyond bringing the hammer down on people. But Clarey was the day-to-day manager, the detail person, the enforcer, the one who was often asked to deliver the bad news. She performed a similar role in the campaign, well enough to impress the new governor with her skills. Clarey is not the kind of person who craves publicity. In fact, she hates talking to the press. So I think she will see her role in this administration, as any good chief of staff would, to see to it that the governor's will is implemented, at least as far as the edges of the vast executive branch. We will know more about how Schwarzenegger's views on state policy will be shaped when we see how he and Clarey fill out the rest of the staff. Insiders, meanwhile, already are wondering who will be paired with Clarey as the good cop in this administration, someone to smooth over the hurt feelings after the chief has had her say? My guess: Schwarzenegger.
Posted by dweintraub at 5:15 PM
Patricia Clarey has been appointed chief of staff by Gov.-elect Arnold Schwarzenegger.
Posted by dweintraub at 1:40 PM
The Bee says Gov.-elect Arnold Schwarzenegger is intrigued by a proposal from LA developer, Democrat, Davis supporter, and now transition team member Eli Broad to create a special bipartisan commission to examine the budget and recommend a mega-solution with painful measures normally opposed by members of one party or the other, or both. The idea is that the commission would put a plan before the Legislature with deep spending cuts and structural reforms read, tax increases and lawmakers would then vote up or down on the package without amendment. The commission idea is modeled after the method Congress used to eliminate obsolete military bases, and a proposal Sen. Tom McClintock has long pushed to kill off unneeded portions of the state bureaucracy. But the idea of including tax increases in the plan would probably kill it with members of the Legislatures Republican caucuses, who oppose revenue raisers on principle and believe the budget ought to be balanced with cuts and borrowing alone. And while some form of a commission namely the kind McClintock proposed might have appeal as a way to get at obsolete but protected state functions, the version Broad is pushing would be a political trap for the new governor. Schwarzenegger ran on the idea of providing strong leadership. If, instead, he backed this notion, the new governor would be handing over his most important responsibility to an unelected body of experts and fixers. He would be left to twiddle his thumbs in the governors office for weeks or months waiting for the august body to deliver forth its fiscal dream, which he would then be under immense pressure to support, no matter what was in it. Intriguing idea or not, something tells me that Eli Broad will soon be joining investment guru Warren Buffett on the sit-up pad Schwarzenegger reserves for Democrat moneymen who urge him to raise taxes.
Posted by dweintraub at 5:53 AM
Gray Davis has appointed David Rosenberg, with whom he has worked off and on since their days in the Jerry Brown Administration, to a judgeship on the Superior Court in Yolo County. Rosenberg, 56, is a Yolo County supervisor and director of Community and Intergovernmental Relations for the governor's office. He has served as chairman of the state Lottery, chairman of the California Law Revision Commission, acting Chairman of the Victim Compensation and Government Claims Board, member of the Commission on State Mandates, chairman of the Yolo-Solano Air Quality Management District and member of the Council on Criminal Justice. He was deputy executive secretary and deputy chief of staff for Brown, serving under Davis, from 1976 until 1981.
Posted by dweintraub at 7:49 PM
Common Cause's Recall Money Line newsletter notes that for the second time in a little over a month, "an Indian tribe has reached an agreement with the Davis administration on a compact to permit casino gambling within days of making a substantial contribution to the campaign to keep Davis in office."
The pact with the Fort Mojave Tribe announced Monday was agreed upon on Oct. 3, according to a San Diego Union article, four days after the tribe donated $25,000 to the committee defending Gov. Gray Davis and the same amount to Bustamante. It was the first time that the tribe had made a major political contribution in California, according to Common Cause. In September, the group said, the La Posta Tribe made a $50,000 contribution to Davis, also its first, just nine days after signing a compact.
"This certainly gives the appearance that making a financial contribution to save the governor's job was an unwritten component of the compacts negotiated during the recall," says executive director Jim Knox.
NOTE: Unfortunately, Common Cause's newsletter is not online.
Posted by dweintraub at 3:34 PM
State Treasurer Phil Angelides says Gov.-elect Arnold Schwarzenegger must quickly provide a “Plan B” to ensure that the state can pay its bills if the courts strike down $13 billion in borrowing on which the 2003-04 budget was built. Angelides, in a press conference in his Capitol office, said no one can guarantee that two major bond measures under challenge in the courts will survive legal scrutiny. If the bond sales are struck down as illegal or otherwise tied up in litigation, the state will lack the cash to pay other debts due in June and will see that $13 billion added to its year-end budget deficit. The treasurer says Schwarzenegger must decide almost immediately if he wants to fight the lawsuits, settle them or drop the state's plan to sell the bonds without voter approval, which is the issue at the center of the legal dispute. But Angelides also says he is skeptical of a plan under consideration by Schwarzenegger to restructure the debt and place a new bond measure to cover it before the voters in either March or November of 2004. The treasurer, a Democrat who is considering running for governor in 2006, has said in the past that he thinks any budget solution should include a tax increase. He said Tuesday that a temporary tax increase on those making $250,000 or more per year could pay off the debt in five years. He also said he believes that further spending reductions are possible, and he urged Schwarzenegger to try to reduce the size of the state's structural budget gap before refinancing the debt. Asked whether he thought Schwarzenegger could rescind the recent increase in the car tax, preserve education spending as he has promised and still balance the budget without a tax increase, Angelides said: “I think it’s very tough. The math is very difficult.” The treasurer said he spoke by phone with Schwarzenegger last week and found him “plugged in” and “very attuned” to the state’s shaky fiscal situation. The two plan to meet in person later this week.
NOTE: This item was revised after posting to clarify the treasurer's comments on a possible tax increase.
Posted by dweintraub at 11:12 AM
Gray Davis reaches a deal on a compact for a Southern California gaming tribe. The Bee's story suggests it's consistent with the kind of agreements Schwarzenegger has said he would like to reach with the Indians.
The Times (registration required) says the compact doesn't meet Schwarzenegger's standards, and adds that more may be coming before Gray leaves office. Ultimately, any compact signed now will have to be ratified by the Legislature and signed into law by the new governor before it takes effect.
Posted by dweintraub at 6:10 PM
Gov.-elect Schwarzenegger is scheduled to return to the limelight this week with his first visit to the Capitol since the election, including a series of meetings with legislative leaders Wednesday and a sit-down with recalled Gov. Gray Davis on Thursday. Schwarzenegger has kept a fairly low profile since Oct. 7. After two press conferences in two days to bask in the victory and introduce his transition team, he jetted off to his Sun Valley, Idaho vacation home, where the ski slope named "Arnold's Run" suddenly has taken on a whole new meaning. There he relaxed for the weekend with his family, recharging his batteries after the draining, 62-day campaign while keeping in touch by phone with his transition staff back in California. Last week’s only public appearance was his meeting with President Bush in Riverside and the new governor’s introduction of the prez in San Bernardino, followed by a short solo press conference to talk up “mutual trust” and state/federal relations.
In private, meanwhile, Schwarzenegger has been meeting to shape his governing team with a close circle of advisers, the most important of whom are his wife, Maria, and longtime friends Paul Wachter and Bonnie Reiss. Wachter, who is Schwarzenegger’s personal financial adviser, has known him since 1981, when they met through Maria’s brother Bobby. Wachter began managing the actor’s financial portfolio in the mid-1990s and served as his spokesman on personal financial issues during the campaign. But his influence now extends beyond money. Reiss, a former entertainment industry lawyer and environmental activist, also came to Schwarzenegger more than 20 years ago through her friendship with Maria. She later emerged as the key person in the growth of Schwarzenegger’s favorite charity, the Inner-City Games, for which she has served as CEO and as a member of the board of directors.
Maria Shriver, Bonnie Reiss and Paul Wachter are Schwarzenegger’s anchors, the people who were with him before politics and will be with him after. When they speak, he knows they have his interests at heart. Outside that very close personal circle, the most influential adviser is surely Bob White, the longtime alter ego of former Gov. Pete Wilson and a political mentor to Schwarzenegger since the early 1990s. Rep. David Dreier, the head of the transition committee and a key campaign adviser, serves as something of a balance to White’s Wilsonian instincts, with Republican Senate leader Jim Brulte, a recent addition to the team, an increasingly important part of the mix. Campaign message men Mike Murphy and Don Sipple, neither of whom will enter the government, remain on good terms with Schwarzenegger and will keep him apprised of how he’s doing politically.
While the 65-member transition committee was thrown together hastily and had the unmistakable mark of the Wilson team that helped run the campaign, Schwarzenegger made at least one interesting mid-course adjustment, personally calling Fresno Mayor Alan Autry and asking him to “Join Arnold” after criticism that the list was heavy on Sacramento insiders and light on Central Valley representation. But the transition committee, as everyone knows, is mostly symbolic anyway, with its only real function being to funnel potential appointees the governor's way and, in this case, assess the condition of the various state agencies that the governor-elect will soon direct. Schwarzenegger's real focus the past 12 days has been on the first and perhaps most important decision he will make as governor: naming his chief of staff.
The position is crucial in any government, because the chief-of-staff sets the tone for everything that happens inside the administration. He or she generally serves as the gatekeeper, deciding who sees the governor and who does not. The chief also oversees hiring of the lesser positions on the governor’s personal staff and screens those whose selection requires the governor’s involvement. And this is the person who will help Schwarzenegger decide how much of his ambitious agenda he can tackle, and when.
The governor-elect will want someone who is loyal and long known to him, knows the Capitol and California politics, can manage a huge operation with good people skills and is not afraid to take chances and be bold in implementing Schwarzenegger’s vision. But there is probably no single person who meets all those needs. So he is going to have to choose between someone he knows and trusts implicitly and someone who knows their way around the Capitol but is not as personally familiar with Schwarzenegger's inner thinking.
Some around Schwarzenegger have thought that Reiss would make an inspired choice. Probably no one other than Maria knows Schwarzenegger's professional side as well as Reiss does. Like White did for Wilson, she probably knows Arnold well enough to guess, accurately, what he would do on countless decisions too small to bring to his attention. But her lack of government experience or a big-time management background would make her a risky choice. As would her recent appointment as a director of a major Las Vegas casino company -- a sore point with the Indian gaming tribes with which Schwarzenegger tangled during the campaign. And it's not even known if she would want the job.
An early candidate from outside the inner circle, recommended by White, was Russell Gould, a former finance director and health and welfare secretary for Wilson who since the mid-1990s has been a director with the Los Angeles-based investment firm MetWest, where he has been heavily involved in managing the assets of the Getty Trust. But Gould, friends say, is reluctant to leave his high-paying post and relatively sedate lifestyle for a return to the intense, 24-7 environment of Capitol politics.
Another top candidate, lately emerging as the favorite, is Patricia Clarey, a make-the-trains-run-on-time White deputy during the Wilson years who filled the same job on the Schwarzenegger campaign, which she joined after taking a leave of absence from her post as government relations VP at the health insurer HealthNet. Clarey would be a safe choice: smart, qualified, experienced, a known quantity. She worked for Reagan and the first Bush in Washington before moving west to join the Wilson team. Her selection would raise few eyebrows, other than for the Wilson connection, and perhaps her long ago role as a Chevron Corp. lobbyist. Which is probably just the way she’d like it. Clarey's relative anonymity is something that no doubt makes her an attractive candidate for the job.
But -- and this has to be the caveat in every Schwarzenegger item -- the world learned on Aug. 6 that Arnold loves head-fakes. So I wouldn’t be shocked if he switched gears at the last minute and went with some kind of eye-popping, out-of-the-box selection that caused everybody to stop and say “Wow!” He did name Willie Brown to his transition team, after all.
Posted by dweintraub at 6:19 PM
The Bee takes a look at Schwarzenegger fiscal adviser Donna Arduin's record trimming budgets in Florida, New York and Michigan. She's described as a woman with a good heart but one who is not afraid to slice health and social services to the poor in the quest to balance a budget.
Posted by dweintraub at 6:35 AM
Democrat Atty. Gen. Bill Lockyer says he voted for Republican Arnold Schwarzenegger for governor. Lockyer, speaking at a recall post-mortem at UC Berkeley, said he opposed the recall but chose Schwarzenegger in the replacement election because he stood for "hope, change, reform, opportunity, upbeat problem solving." He added, "I want that. I'm tired of transactional, cynical, dealmaking politics." Lockyer, considered a frontrunner for the Democratic nomination for governor in 2006, would have had to challenge an incumbent of his own party had Lt. Gov. Cruz Bustamante been elected this year. Lockyer didn't directly criticize Bustamante Saturday but said he looked at the list of candidates and it was "a crappy list." Lockyer said his vote for Schwarzenegger was his first for a Republican in a partisan race in his life. "I hope I haven't been conned," he said.
UPDATE: In comments to reporters after his speech, Lockyer had this to say about why he didn't vote for his fellow Democrat: "You know the people in your profession really well. You know who works hard and who doesn't. You know who is honest and who isn't. Cops know that about cops. Doctors know that about doctors. I know that about politicians. The common thing to all these professions is none of them say it. That's all I'm going to say."
Posted by dweintraub at 1:33 PM
Arnold and the schools: Every new California governor takes office with a pledge to respect local control of the schools. And every one of them then signs legislation increasing Sacramento control over the schools. The advantage of the accountability movement begun by Pete Wilson, expanded by Gray Davis and endorsed by Arnold Schwarzenegger is that it allows the state to set consistent standards, assess how those standards are being met and then hold the schools accountable for their performance. It also should allow the state to free local schools to meet those standards more or less as they see fit. But that part hasnt happened. Schwarzenegger, like his predecessors, says he supports local control. Among other things he wants to cut the strings on millions of dollars the state sends the districts in categorical grants limited to specific purposes. Davis proposed something similar but backed down when he met opposition from narrow groups that wanted to preserve the mandates. It will be interesting to see if Schwarzenegger stands by his pledge. Here is an AP story that takes an early look at his views on education.
Posted by dweintraub at 10:38 AM
Foiled by the radio gods: I am blogging today from beautiful Mendocino, where Ive come today to talk to a local group about the recall and the future of California politics. After a relaxing morning stroll along the bluffs, I found a wireless-ready locally owned coffeehouse (no Starbucks allowed here!), and Ive set myself up with a latte, a muffin and my laptop. My drive over Thursday night was marred by my belated discovery that no Northern California radio station was airing the seventh game of the American League Championship Series live. The horror! What made it even worse was knowing that two stations I knew of had access to the game and were choosing not to air it, relying instead on local programming, mostly sports talk. A Sacramento sports radio station had two talkers on after the NBA Kings pre-season game, and, as if to torture their listeners, the hosts were groaning and grunting about the game as they watched the Yankees comeback on television without telling us what was actually happening. A San Francisco station, meanwhile, had an interview with the former owner of the 49ers, who assured Bay Area football fans that the team would still be competitive if he were still in charge. I lost contact with the Sacramento station as I approached the coast, and the San Francisco station finally put the game on as it reached extra innings (showing great courage by postponing their weekly Fantasy Football hour). But this station insisted on cutting to its local host between innings, and he would say a few words before sending listeners back to the network feed. Of course, he waited too long in the middle of the 11th, and when he sent us back, all we got was play-by-play man Jon Miller recapping Aaron Boones first-pitch, game-winning homerun. Idiots.
UPDATE: I asked one of the clerks at the coffee shop if their wireless hotspot was popular. He said, well, yeah, with the people who know it's here. We don't really advertise it, he said. Seems that people in these parts might not like the idea. The
Posted by dweintraub at 9:39 AM
Schwarzenegger, Bush meet in SB: Schwarzenegger and Bush have made their first joint appearance since the recall election. Introducing Bush in San Bernardino, Schwarzenegger said when he arrived on these shores 35 years ago, he never dreamed he'd one day be governor and introducing the president. But California, he said, "is a place of great dreams." His current dream is to get a few billion out of the federal government to help him balance the budget. He mentioned the state's "serious challenges" and said California has "no greater ally" in Washington than Bush. The president, in turn, after joking that "some accuse both of us of not being able to speak the language," predicted that Schwarzenegger will be "a fine and strong leader for California." No specifics, of course, and don't expect any when the governor-elect holds a press conference a few minutes after Bush's speech.
Matt Miller in this commentary correctly skewers the Schwarzenegger argument that California deserves more federal money because it has been paying in more than it gets back from Washington. But Schwarzenegger's argument on the burden of illegal immigration is more specific, and more credible. If he succeeds in his drive for more federal money, it's going to be after a finely choreographed campaign involving several big states with high levels of immigration.
Today he will probably just say that he began to lay out his case and the president was open to his arguments.
Posted by dweintraub at 9:45 AM
McClintock protegé and ally Tony Strickland announces that he will challenge Barbara Boxer for the U.S. Senate next year. I expect former Secretary of State Bill Jones to be next to announce, and to emerge as the establishment choice for the Republican nomination.
Posted by dweintraub at 9:37 AM
The California Broadcasters Assn., sponsors of the widely watched Sept. 24 debate, held a session Wednesday night to review the event and the reaction to it. CBA director Marc Powers said estimates suggest that half the televisions that were turned on in California that night were tuned to the debate. The CBA received nearly 50,000 e-mails and 10,000 letters about the event. Reviews were generally positive. Three out of four who wrote in said the program was either informative, entertaining and/or a valuable tool for making their decisions. Two out of three liked seeing the questions come from voters, and half said they liked the fact that the questions were released in advance. As for moderator Stan Statham: two out of three said what Powers described as "a good job under the circumstances." The CBA is hoping to sponsor a similar debate during next year's U.S. Senate campaign.
Posted by dweintraub at 7:27 AM
The Bee reports that at least eight local television stations have decided to open bureaus in Sacramento to cover the Schwarzenegger Administration -- or at least the start of it. The betting has already begun on when they'll grow bored and leave town again. I hope they stay. It's been 15 years since the last outta town TV news bureau pulled up stakes. I think the light they shine on the process is needed to help keep voters informed about their government.
Posted by dweintraub at 7:12 AM
Controller Steve Westly, a first-term Democrat thinking about running for governor in 2006, reached out today to Gov.-elect Schwarzenegger on several fronts. Westly, after having some fun offering a mock screenplay for the new governor (“The Road to Reform”) along with a director’s chair and fresh hot popcorn on the Capitol steps, said:
-- He agrees that Schwarzenegger, or his director of finance, can reduce the car tax by administrative order, but he encouraged Schwarzenegger to reimburse cities and counties from the state budget for the loss of revenue.
-- He thinks the Schwarzenegger audit is a good idea but wants to go further, proposing performance audits of every state agency to determine whether the taxpayers are getting their money’s worth.
-- Endorsed a bigger budget reserve, stricter spending limits and the withholding of salaries for top state officials when a budget is late.
Westly also endorsed redistricting reform, which Schwarzenegger has proposed, and called on the new governor to back his open primary initiative.
“We have a logjam in Sacramento,” Westly said. “We need to break that. I get it.”
Posted by dweintraub at 3:35 PM
The Washington Times speculates that Rep. David Dreier, political-friend-in-chief to the new gov, might challenge Barbara Boxer for the U.S. Senate next year.
Posted by dweintraub at 8:32 AM
This isn't set in stone, but I am hearing that the most likely date for a Schwarzenegger swearing in is Nov. 17, a Monday.
Posted by dweintraub at 8:19 AM
Wesley Clark has come from nowhere to vault into the lead among Democrats competing in the California presidential primary, a new Field Poll shows. Clark is the choice of 17 percent of California Democrats, ahead of both Howard Dean and Joe Lieberman, who are tied at 14. Dean had built a big lead before Clark jumped into the race. In the last Field Poll, the former Vermont governor led Lieberman 23-15. Kerry, who was third, drops to fourth. The poll also shows Bush competitive in California with all the major Democrat contenders, with the president holding small leads over Dean, Kerry, Lieberman and Gephardt while trailing Clark narrowly. Here is the entire poll.
Posted by dweintraub at 6:47 AM
While many people at the impression that the Legislature and Gray Davis were rushing to enact their agenda both before and after the recall election, that didn't show up in the numbers. Or maybe they concentrated on the big stuff. Anyway, Davis signed fewer bills into law this year than any governor dating back to Ronald Reagan, according to longtime state Senate staffer Peter Detwiler, who keeps a record of the annual stats. Below are the highlights of this year's Detwiler report:
Davis signed the lowest number of bills of any recent governor, just 909 in 2003.
Davis also signed the second-lowest number of bills of any recent governor (948 in 2001).
The highest percentage of bills vetoed (24.91%) came from Davis in 2000.
The most vetoes in a single year (436) came from Deukmejian in 1990.
Deukmejian also vetoed the most bills (2,298).
In five years, Davis vetoed twice as many bills (1,098) as (Jerry) Brown did in his eight years (528).
In 1982, Brown vetoed just 30 bills, setting the record for the lowest number of vetoes.
Wilson signed the fewest bills of any recent (two-term) governor; 9,324 over eight years.
But Davis holds the record for the lowest annual average (1,029 a year over five years).
The five years with the highest number of chaptered bills were all with Republican governors (1971, 1984, 1967, 1990, 1988).
Although usually regarded as political conservatives, Deukmejian and Reagan actually signed more bills than Brown, the more activist liberal.
Most odd-numbered years have fewer new laws, probably because they are the first years of two-year legislative sessions. There are four exceptions: 1967, 1971, 1985, and 1993.
Posted by dweintraub at 5:31 PM
Former Gov. Pete Wilson and former Assembly Speaker Bob Hertzberg will discuss the recall and its implcations for the future at a forum at the Mayflower Hotel in Washington on Thursday. The discussion is scheduled to be webcast at 1:15 p.m. Pacific Time here.
Posted by dweintraub at 3:59 PM
More names floated in the Arnold chief of staff derby, with the understanding that in jobs like this, it’s often the name that never surfaces that matters most:
-- Kathleen Shanahan, a former Wilson administration official who also worked for the Bush 41 campaign in 1992 and for Dick Cheney during the 2000 presidential campaign. She recently resigned as chief of staff to Florida Gov. Jeb Bush after serving in that post for three years.
-- Patricia Clarey, former deputy chief of staff to Wilson, and Bob White’s deputy in the Schwarzenegger campaign operation. Clarey took a leave from her job as vice president for governmental relations for HealthNet to work for Schwarzenegger.
Also, a number of members of the transition committee are pushing for the selection of Cassandra Pye, vice president for corporate affairs at the California Chamber of Commerce, where she has been the political eyes and ears for the chamber for several years.
Posted by dweintraub at 3:55 PM
Columnist Jill Stewart publishes her own response to Los Angeles Times editor John Carroll's comments on the Schwarzenegger groping stories, and adds a long interview with a Times' insider describing the investigative team that was let loose on "the actor." These two items, especially the insider's take, will be must reading for people who can't get enough of this story behind the story.
I have defended the original Times groping story and don't believe allegations that the piece was held for effect. But as all the dust settles, I do think two key questions about the paper's coverage have yet to be fully answered:
-- Why didn't The Times dedicate equivalent resources to investigating reports of Davis' ill temper and his treatment of his subordinates?
-- Why, if it took The Times seven weeks to confirm its first six allegations of groping, was the paper able to get 8 more charges into print in a matter of days after its expose was published?
Posted by dweintraub at 2:49 PM
The Bee's Aurelio Rojas takes a look at Schwarzenegger's potential relationship with the Legislature's Latino caucus, including hints of a possible compromise on driver's licenses. Republican Assemblyman Abel Maldonado also suggests that Schwarzenegger can win 60 percent of the Latino vote if he runs for reelection in 2006.
Posted by dweintraub at 7:39 AM
Russell Gould, managing director of MetWest Financial and a former official in the Pete Wilson Administration, is a leading candidate to serve as Arnold Schwarzenegger’s chief of staff, my sources tell me. Another way of putting that: the Schwarzenegger braintrust would love to have Gould, but it's not clear at all that he would like the job. Gould long ago left the government grind behind for the rarified air of corporate finance, also serving for a time as senior vice president at the J. Paul Getty Trust. But if Gould could be coaxed out of his high-paying Los Angeles job for a return gig in Sacramento, he would be an interesting choice. He was Wilson’s first Health and Welfare Secretary, and in that post oversaw the difficult budget cuts of the early 1990s recession as well as the first pass at welfare reform in California, long before it emerged as a big national issue. At the same time he helped Wilson fashion a “preventive agenda” aimed at getting kids off to a good start in life with prenatal care, early childhood health care and other school-based programs. In short, he helped Wilson shape a compassionate conservative agenda for California before George W. Bush ever heard of the term. Both the compassion and the conservatism would probably appeal to California’s new governor, who must find a way to make serious cuts in programs while also living up to his promise to make children’s issues the top social priority of his administration. Gould, who was also finance director for Wilson, was never known as a terribly political animal, though, judging by his rise from state bureaucrat to high-flying financier in less than a decade, he obviously knows a thing or two about dealing with people. Los Angeles-based MetWest reportedly has more than $50 billion in assets under its management, and its clients include Boeing, Microsoft and the California Public Employees Retirement System.
Other names being floated for the top job also have Wilson connections. They include Gary Hunt, a longtime Wilson associate and former vice president of the Irvine Co., and Bill Hauck, a former Wilson special assistant who is currently president of the California Business Roundtable -- a group that opposed the recall. The only non-Wilson name I have heard, former Assembly Speaker Curt Pringle, currently the mayor of Anaheim, seems like a longshot at this point.
Posted by dweintraub at 3:25 PM
In one of his final decisions on legislation as governor, Gray Davis late last night vetoed SB 328, which would have allowed low-income illegal immigrants to have their fees waived at California Community Colleges.Here is a PDF file of the governor's veto message. More on this and other last-minute vetoes and signings as the dust settles on about 200 bills Davis acted on over the weekend.
Posted by dweintraub at 5:58 AM
Don't miss Matt Labash's deliciously detailed account of the final days of the Schwarzenegger campaign, as told from a pack of hundreds of journalists with no access to the candidate and nothing of substance to write about. At the Weekly Standard.
Posted by dweintraub at 8:07 AM
This LA Times story based on exit polling in the recall suggests that Democrats might have a hard time keeping upwardly mobile Latinos in their camp. As Latinos' income goes up, so does their tendency to vote Republican.
Posted by dweintraub at 12:24 PM
Here is a Chronicle story on Schwarzenegger's plan for straightening out California's energy mess. Another proposal he made during a campaign that was supposedly substance-free.
Posted by dweintraub at 7:49 AM
Rick Hasen has been tracking several analyses about how the undervotes in the recall election varied across different kinds of voting systems, and what that might tell us. His latest take is here.
Posted by dweintraub at 7:35 AM
Gray reads the Top 10 list on Letterman tonight. Sneak preview from the governor's office:
TOP TEN PIECES OF ADVICE GRAY DAVIS HAS FOR ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER
10. "WHEN YOU REALIZE YOU DON'T KNOW WHAT YOU'RE DOING, GIVE ME A CALL"
9. "BABY OIL WILL STAIN THE MANSION'S ITALIAN SILK SOFA"
8. "LISTEN TO YOUR CONSTITUENTS - EXCEPT MICHAEL JACKSON"
7. (SORRY, JOKE NUMBER 7 WAS RECALLED)
6. "TO IMPROVE YOUR APPROVAL RATING, GO ON LENO - WHEN YOU GET KICKED OUT, GO ON LETTERMAN"
5. "STUDY THE MASTER - GEORGE W. BUSH" (laughs) "AH, I'M JUST KIDDING"
4. "YOU COULD SOLVE THE DEFICIT PROBLEM BY DONATING YOUR SALARY FROM 'TERMINATOR 3'"
3. "IF THINGS ARE BAD, JUST YELL, 'SAVE US, SUPERMAN!'"
2. "WHILE GIVING A SPEECH, NEVER SAY, 'SANTA CRUZ, SANTA BARBARA...SAME THING"
1. IT'S PRONOUNCED 'CALIFORNIA'"
Posted by dweintraub at 6:53 PM
Gov. Gray Davis will be signing, and presumably vetoing, legislation through the weekend leading up to his midnight Sunday deadline for taking action on bills sent to his desk at the end of the legislative session. His office just announced that Davis has signed 66 bills. Look here for a list of those measures soon, and for updates through the weekend.
Posted by dweintraub at 4:39 PM
Still catching up on loose ends. This New Democrat newsletter from the Democratic Leadership Council cautions party members not to go to war with Schwarzenegger but to hold him accountable while also tending to big problems of their own. Money quote:
"Democrats also need to tend to their own garden and take very seriously the decision of California voters -- who still decisively tilt Democratic in party identification and overall policy views -- to support what began as a nutty right-wing crusade and ended as a popular movement. They need to regain their centrist, problem-solving reputation, and must absolutely reverse the recent perception that they don't give a damn about anybody who doesn't belong to a reliable Democratic constituency group. California voters can help both parties move away from the current polarization by approving a ballot initiative next year that would bring back an open primary system -- re-enfranchising moderate and independent voters, and re-engaging today's isolated parties in a competition to win elections through new ideas and successful governance."
Posted by dweintraub at 11:48 AM
The suburban Sacramento offices of People's Advocate, where recall sponsor Ted Costa is the chief executive officer, were egged last night, according to Costa assistant Carl Burton. Burton said the windows and door of the office were covered with splattered eggs. The group has filed a police report on the incident.
Posted by dweintraub at 10:31 AM
Here is the complete list of transition committee members.
Posted by dweintraub at 7:12 AM
Arnold Schwarzenegger has chosen Donna Arduin, the director of Florida’s Department of Finance, to conduct the independent audit of California’s books he promised during the recall campaign. Arduin, a Duke University graduate who has also worked for the state of New York and Michigan and as an analyst for Morgan Stanley & Co., is taking leave from the Florida administration of Gov. Jeb Bush and donating her time to do the Schwarzenegger audit, according to transition spokesman Rob Stutzman.
While the scope of the audit isn’t yet clear, Arduin said she intends to complete it in time for Schwarzenegger to include her recommendations in his first budget, which must go to the Legislature by Jan. 10.
Don’t look for this to be the top-to-bottom examination of potential waste and fraud in state government. That will come later. Arduin, at least in the first pass, will probably limit herself to establishing a definitive number for the state deficit and listing all the borrowing, diversions, and tricks upon which the current budget rests. Look for her also to perhaps recommend a few structural reforms, including the spending cap Schwarzenegger wants, and possibly a way to restructure the state’s debt.
According to the transition team press release, Arduin in Florida has implemented a system where agencies and departments annually map out the cost and demand for each service they provide, with five-year forecasts for each. She favors performance-based budgeting under which departments attach “real-world performance measures” to each activity and connect outcome goals to budget dollars.
Here is an interesting and not too flattering view of her performance by a columnist at the St. Pete Times.
Posted by dweintraub at 3:17 PM
Gov.-elect Schwarzenegger today unveiled a transition team whose ideological breadth could bridge the Central Valley. It runs from Bill Simon on the right to Willie Brown on the left and includes just about every imaginable spot in between. Despite Simon’s presence, the team does not appear heavily weighted to the right. Most of the Republicans are of the more moderate stripe – people like former Assemblywoman Charlene Zettel and former state Sen. Rebecca Morgan. One of the more notable names on the list is Tammy Bruce, former president of the LA chapter of the National Organization for Women and a member of the group’s board of directors. She was a Schwarzenegger supporter during the campaign.
Others: Orange County Sheriff Mike Carona, Sen. Jim Brulte, Jon Coupal, president of the Howard Jarvis Tazpayers Assn., USC law professor Susan Estrich, former state Treasurer Matt Fong, LA Mayor Jim Hahn, former Assembly Speaker Robert Hertzberg, Robin Kramer, a former Dick Riordan aide, investor Gerald Parsky, who is Bush’s man in California, Cassandra Pye of the California Chamber of Commerce, and many more.
These lists are not always meaningful, of course. They are meant, more than anything, to set a tone and send early signals about a new administration’s direction. The names on the list become conduits for people seeking an appointment in the government. But Schwarzenegger has certainly, with this list, delivered the message that he intends to govern from the center while reaching out to both the left and the right.
Transition spokesman Rob Stutzman said legislative leaders have agreed on a $500,000 transition budget for Schwarzenegger (same as Davis and Wilson had) and a $100,000 budget for Davis to tie up his affairs.
Posted by dweintraub at 2:56 PM
The Oakland Tribune reports that veteran state Sen. John Vasconcellos, a longtime advocate of the self-esteem movement, thinks that the new governor is a "boob" and might quit the Legislature rather than serve alongside Schwarzenegger in Sacramento.
Posted by dweintraub at 9:48 AM
Trying to divine Gov.-elect Schwarzenegger’s likely moves on fiscal policy is a little bit like the old practice of Kremlinology, where analysts had to parse vague statements, watch personnel shifts and consider history to figure out what might happen next. One of the major stories of the campaign was that Schwarzenegger was being vague about his ideas on the budget. I said so many times myself. But now that he has been elected governor and I am trying to assess where he is going from here, I find myself coming back to his many statements during the campaign that gave us broad hints about the direction he intended to take. It turns out that he was more specific than we sometimes gave him credit for, if only you had time to use a careful ear and a bit of imagination. Stitched together and filled in by informed speculation, his fragmentary statements can be used to make some educated guesses about the near future. Would I prefer a candidate, or a governor-elect, who speaks more clearly, directly and specifically about his plans? Absolutely. But this is what we’ve got at the moment, so let’s make the best of it.
I’ve already written at some length about his hopes for federal money, which he mentioned several times during the campaign, even if it was largely ignored by the political press corps. I also think he has a decent chance of cutting a deal with the gaming tribes to contribute something to the state’s general fund.
Now I want to address something else he said over and over during the race: restructuring the state’s debt. What might that mean?
The current state budget rests upon billions of dollars in borrowing, shifts, accounting gimmicks and the like. The famous “audit” that Schwarzenegger mentioned repeatedly during the campaign is probably going to amount to a definitive statement of all of those smoke-and-mirror tactics and what they mean for the state’s fiscal condition. I don’t take literally Schwarzenegger’s comment that this audit will uncover the waste in government. That’s a project that will take months or years to complete. But unlike skeptics who laugh off the audit as a meaningless delaying tactic, I think it would be useful to have in one place at one time a comprehensive analysis of all the shifts and diversions in the budget -- legal and illegal -- to give us a complete sense of the state’s fiscal condition. The Legislative Analyst has done some of this kind of work, but I have seen nothing yet that lays out the entire picture in context.
Next, consider the two major pieces of the budget plan that are most at risk. A scheme to borrow money to pay the state’s obligation to its employee pension fund has already been struck down by a court on grounds that it violates a constitutional provision against borrowing more than $300,000 without a vote of the people. Another, much larger deficit bond is vulnerable to the same kind of legal attack and might yet fall as well. Together the two measures total $13 billion. If they are both struck down, the state will be essentially insolvent, with no ability to borrow to get the money it needs to pay its bills.
Suppose Gov. Schwarzenegger gets an audit which makes this clear and also lays out the looming $8 billion gap between projected spending and revenues in the fiscal year that begins July 1. Now let’s remember several other things he said during the campaign:
The accumulated deficit might be as large as “$20 billion.”
He wants to “restructure the debt.”
He wants to start over fiscally with “a clean slate.”
He wants to adopt a spending cap.
He wants to prohibit future deficit spending.
That’s actually quite a bit of specificity for a guy who supposedly never told us where he was headed. What he didn’t do was tie it all together for us. Now I will try to do that.
What if he does the audit, concludes that we have a $20 billion problem, says Davis tried to circumvent the will of the people by bonding without a vote, and asks the Legislature to put the following on the March ballot:
--A $20 billion bond to finance the accumulated debt and help cover the gap emerging in next year’s budget. (“Restructure the debt.”)
--A constitutional amendment to clearly prohibit future deficit spending without a vote of the people.
--A spending cap or reserve requirement to prevent this from happening again.
He could sell this plan as the only way to avoid big tax increases or devastating spending cuts, the only politically palatable way to get the state out of the fix left for him by his predecessor. It would find favor with Republican legislators who oppose tax increases (and were the first to propose the deficit bond this year) and Democrats who don’t want to vote for spending cuts. It would give the state time to grow out of its problem. And while it could be criticized as more deficit spending, if it were coupled with a spending cap and a clear ban on future borrowing without a vote of the people it could be described as short-term relief combined with long-term reform. It would probably get the support of every major interest group in the state, from labor to business to the anti-tax crowd that started the recall.
And it would be entirely consistent with everything Schwarzenegger said as a candidate.
One last thing: what got Davis in trouble was his lack of boldness, his refusal to attack problems before they became crises. The looming legal challenge to the deficit bonds is one more such disaster-in-waiting. A timid governor would wait and see if the courts strike it down, then be forced to react in a panic to pick up the pieces. A bold, forward-thinking governor would say, what can we do to avoid that kind of situation? The answer: go to the people proactively for the authority that only they can provide, settle the lawsuit, wipe the slate clean and then balance the operating budget going forward.
Posted by dweintraub at 8:25 AM
Late last night, just before Gray Davis conceded defeat in a gracious speech, I spoke at his event with Sen. Sheila Kuehl, the Santa Monica Democrat who hopes to replace John Burton next year as leader of the state Senate. Kuehl is a partisan liberal, head of the “Progressive PAC” that raises money for leftist Democrats running in legislative primaries. She is also usually level-headed, pleasant, intelligent and courteous. Last night, she was none of the above. Here is an excerpt from our interview:
DW: How are you feeling?
KUEHL: I am really sad. I’m more angry than anything. And I haven’t even started thinking about what the Senate will need to do in order to save the state.
DW: Save the state from what?
KUEHL: From ignorance. This guy has no idea how to run a state. One of two things will happen. He’ll have his own ideas and no way to carry them out. I mean he has already proposed three things that the governor cannot do. He wants to roll back the car tax on his own by fiat, which he can t do. He wants to tax the Indians, which he can’t do. He doesn’t know anything about running the state. So either he will propose a lot of stuff he can’t do and we’ll have to govern, or he’ll be pretty well manipulated by people who have an agenda, very much the way I think the president of the United States has been handled by people who are really telling him how to do these things. In which case we may have to counteract things that are worse than things he proposed on his own. His handlers will probably be more conservative than he is, or in the Republican Party line. Convince him he’ll bring businesses back to the state by cutting more benefits to workers, by unraveling anti-discrimination statutes which they call job killers.
DW: Will he be received civilly by the Democrats in the Legislature?
KUEHL: He will be received civilly. We have received everyone civilly. I don’t know if everybody is going to go to the State of the State (speech). Because frankly I don’t think there is going to be a lot of content that anyone’s interested in. What’s this guy got to say to us about the state of the state? Nothing.
Posted by dweintraub at 9:27 AM
Schwarzenegger won a plurality in 50 of the 58 counties, and took an outright majority in 36 of them. All of the counties where he finished second to Cruz are clustered around San Francisco Bay or around the north and central coasts. His best county was Sutter, the rural county north of Sacramento, where he got a whopping 65 percent of the vote. Interestingly, the better Schwarzenegger did in those counties, the better McClintock did too. In a handful, Tom finished second. Here is the map.
Posted by dweintraub at 7:24 AM
California has its own version of the blue-state, red-state breakdown, only here the breakdown comes by counties, and the Secretary of State's map colors them green and red. Just 15 of the state's 58 counties opposed the recall yesterday, and eight of them were on the coast. Six of the remaining seven were either continguous to a coastal county and immediately inland, or touching San Francisco Bay. Yolo County, which was 49.8 percent "yes" as of 6:40 this morning, was the only "inland" county for Gray. And other than Los Angeles County, which was 51 percent "no" on the recall, the southernmost county for Gray was Monterey. I will come back with the precise numbers on this, but it appears that if you took away Los Angeles County and those counties which touch SF Bay, the recall would have passed 60-40, and perhaps by an even greater margin. See the map here. Remember to refresh the page.
Posted by dweintraub at 6:56 AM
Among Latinos, 46 percent voted for the recall, while Schwarzenegger (31 percent) and McClintock (9 percent) combined took 40 percent in the replacement election, according to the Edison Media Research/Mitofsky International exit poll commissioned by Associated Press and a consortium of media. Bustamante got 52 percent of the Latino vote.
Posted by dweintraub at 12:22 AM
The LA Times exit poll suggests that the groping stories had an effect: those voters who say they made up their minds before last weekend went 56-44 for the recall and 50-32 for Schwarzenegger over Bustamante. Those who decided last weekend or later went 51-49 for the recall and 38-34 for Schwarzenegger over Bustamante. McClintock's vote went from 13 to 16 and the other candidates rose from 5 percent to 12 percent. Here is a PDF with the full report.
Posted by dweintraub at 12:15 AM
"It was the triumph of the swill," --Gray Davis pollster Paul Maslin, describing Schwarzenegger's victory with a nasty and feeble reference to Leni Riefenstahl's famous 1934 documentary on the rise of Adolf Hitler.
Posted by dweintraub at 12:05 AM
Schwarzenegger's transition team is taking shape, and at least at the top, it is conspicuous by the absence of veterans of the Pete Wilson operation. Rep. David Dreier, the San Dimas Republican, will be chairman, with Jim Richardson, an aide to Senate Republican Leader Jim Brulte, serving as staff director. Rob Stutzman, who was the party spokesman before shifting to the Schwarzenegger campaign, will handle communications. And Dreier's chief of staff, Brad Smith, will also play a key role. Also, look for details to emerge on Schwarzenegger's promised audit of the state's books by week's end.
Posted by dweintraub at 11:29 PM
"It's going to take more than a broom to clean things up in Sacramento," -- Democratic Assembly Speaker Herb Wesson.
Posted by dweintraub at 11:12 PM
I’ve just finished watching Gov. Gray Davis’ concession speech at the Biltmore Hotel, and I have mixed feelings about what has transpired tonight. Even though I knew in my bones that this was coming, even though it seemed inevitable from the time the petitions were certified, if not before then, it still was a shock to the system to see it happen. It is sad, in a way, that the state’s public affairs are in such terrible shape that it has come to this. Despite my feelings about the job Davis did as governor, and my role in documenting his failures, I have little joy in my heart tonight. It is almost as if the state’s voters have fired an employee for whom they once had high hopes, someone who didn’t work out the way we thought he would. That’s nothing to celebrate, when you think about it.
Davis in his concession speech showed class, congratulating Schwarzenegger and promising to cooperate with him during the transition. But his supporters were angry and nasty and in no mood to concede anything.
I understand the bitterness, but I’m disturbed by its depth. Several of the Democrats I spoke to were in strong denial about the message sent by the voters, the message being that they, and Davis, have been poor stewards of state government. They see this is an isolated event, a venting, that will quickly pass while they fight to maintain everything they have done the past five years. My gut tells me they are wrong, that there is something deeper here, a desire for fundamental change in the way the state does business and in the way politics works, or doesn’t work, in California.
They also seem to misunderstand Gov.-elect Schwarzenegger, and what he is all about. His rhetoric is harsh and often shallow, to be sure, but he has laid out a broad vision for the state that the people have accepted. Legislators will ignore that reality at their peril.
Posted by dweintraub at 10:49 PM
Partial transcript of interview with Davis a few minutes ago on CNN's Larry King Live. The gov is not exactly brimming with confidence.
KING: Was it difficult to walk into that booth and see your name listed among should the Governor Gray Davis be recalled?
DAVIS: Well, it wasn't my happiest moment, but I knew it was coming for a long time, so we put on the best campaign we could in 77 days, and even though California has problems, we've made some progress. The tax scores are up five years in a row. And we have a million more children with health insurance. We have the best environmental record in the country, and we're the strongest defenders of a woman's right to choose. So I know the critics complained, but some good things have happened in this state, as well.
KING: Are you surprised at the turnout?
DAVIS: Pleasantly, because I think the bigger the turnout, the more legitimate the results. If it's a big turnout, then everyone had a chance to have their say, and I obviously will abide by the results.
The voters have been good to me, electing me twice as governor, allowing me to serve 35 million people. I'm very grateful to them, very grateful for the opportunity to try and move the state forward, and whatever their judgment is tonight, I will accept it.
KING: So, if you lose, no deep regrets or bitterness?
DAVIS: No. I mean, you have to deal the cards -- play the cards you're dealt. I came in. We had a wonderful economy. We created 1.2 million jobs, everyone was happy. And 300,000 of those jobs we lost the last three years because the national economy has been in a recession, which has affected all 50 states. So it's been tough governing these last three years, but tougher on the people I represent. So I work every day doing whatever I can to improve their lives.
KING: If you do go down tonight, will you cooperate with the governor-elect?
DAVIS: Yes. That's an obligation, I believe. Governor Wilson cooperated in my transition from him to me, and I'll cooperate in the transition, if that's the voters' will, with whoever they choose tonight.
Posted by dweintraub at 6:37 PM
Reports are coming in from around the state that turnout is the heaviest anyone has seen in years. Some of the crowding may be because the number of polling places was reduced in some areas because this was a special election. But here is a stunner: I just heard a radio report from Monterey County saying that police have warned of a huge traffic jam in the northern part of the county. Why? Because so many people are heading to a polling place.
Posted by dweintraub at 6:32 PM
For all the venom hurled the LA Times’ way over the groping allegations, if Schwarzenegger still wins, he might want to thank the paper for doing him a big favor. With that many women out there making these charges, it was inevitable that the issue would surface in volume at some point. If The Times had waited until after a Schwarzenegger victory, should it come, the stories would have created a huge problem for the new governor and cast into doubt the legitimacy of his election. The “Recall Arnold” movement would have started with the groping charges as the foundation of their effort, claiming that voters never would have elected him had they known about his wandering hands. His opponents will still make that argument if he is elected, but now, because of his acknowledgement of bad behavior and his apology, he could credibly argue that the voters knew of his past when they voted and chose him anyway. That is, as long as nothing more serious emerges in the days and weeks ahead.
Posted by dweintraub at 9:59 AM
The Field Poll estimates a huge turnout, the highest number ever for a governor's race and the highest percentage of registered voters for a governor's race in 20 years:
“In today’s historic recall election The Field Poll estimates that as many as ten million California voters will be participating in the decision as to who they want as governor for the next three years. A turnout of this magnitude would represent a 30% increase over the 7.7 million voters who participated in the 2002 gubernatorial election and would be larger than any previous non-presidential contest in state history.”
Look for the whole thing here later this morning.
Posted by dweintraub at 5:30 AM
Here are the final results of the major independent polls that have surveyed California voters on the recall. The date of the last night of polling is in parentheses. The replacement results are listed in this order: Schwarzenegger, Bustamante, McClintock.
Field (Oct. 1) 57-39; 36-26-16
Los Angeles Times (Sept. 29) 56-42; 40-32-15
Knight Ridder/NBC (Oct. 4) 54-41; 37-29-15
CNN/USA Today (Sept. 27) 63-35; 40-25-18
Survey USA (Oct.. 5)* 57-43; 46-34-13
Chamber of Commerce (Sept. 25) 53-41; 35-31-17
Knowledge Networks/Hoover (Oct. 4)** 59-41; 43-30-13
The Public Policy Institute of California, usually a major source on California public opinion, last polled on Sept. 17 and is thus not reliable at this stage in the race. For the record, the poll had the recall winning 53-42 with Bustamante leading Schwarzenegger 28-26 and McClintock at 14.
*Survey USA uses a unique form of polling with recorded voices asking the questions.
**This is an online poll using a random sample.
Posted by dweintraub at 10:30 PM
If anybody loves Gov. Gray Davis, it’s firefighters. He has supported them, giving their unions the right to binding arbitration, which has since been struck down by the courts, and the chance to bargain for pensions that will pay them as much as 90 percent of their salary at age 50. And they have returned the favor, showering his campaign with contributions and serving as the foundation for his campaign to beat the recall.
So it was only fitting that on Monday, in the final hours before the recall election, the governor joined hundreds of firefighters on a march through the streets of San Francisco to a rally in Union Square. On camera, the event will look impressive: a sea of firefighters clad in dark blue “no-recall” t-shirts cheering the governor of California. But 900 of those present were from out of state, attending a national symposium down the street at the Hilton Hotel. They can’t vote for Davis, and they’ll be too busy Tuesday at their conference to work on his behalf. About 300 others at the rally were from fire departments around the San Francisco Bay Area.
Union leaders and San Francisco Mayor Willie Brown delivered passionate speeches for the governor. And they implored the firefighters to help them get out the vote on Tuesday.
“We’re at war!” shouted John Hanley, president of the San Francisco firefighters union.
The international president, Harold Schaitberger, was more graphic.
“I am counting on you to get your asses out there tomorrow and light a fire under the voters of California,” he said. “We’re going to send a message to the Terminator: ‘You can go be the mayor of Muscle Beach but stay the hell out of Sacramento!'”
Mayor Brown, employing a bit of politician’s license, called Davis the greatest governor in California history, and predicted that the state will never see another one as talented as him. If the Democrats can get out the vote, he said, “the shock of everybody’s life will take place and on Wednesday morning Gray Davis will get back to governing this state.”
As Brown spoke, a man with an oversized Arnold Schwarzenegger mask strapped to his face, money in his hands and a large blue E symbolizing Enron pursued a woman dressed in pink around the plaza, groping her between faux slaps in the face.
Then Davis took the stage. He couldn’t match the passion of his warm-up speakers, but he was more animated than usual. He warned the audience that the car-tax cut Schwarzenegger is promising will mean deep cuts in city budgets and layoffs for half the police and firefighters in the state.
“Arnold Schwarzenegger is pulling the wool over your eyes,” Davis said. “He cannot produce a balanced budget. That’s why he says he’ll talk about that after the election.”
Davis added: “This is the time, this is the moment, to send a clear message to the country and the world,” he said. “Californians are fair. Californians are reasonable. Californians are decent people.”
The governor’s words were well received by the firefighters but failed to draw much of a crowd from beyond the center of the plaza -- the same problem, in miniature, that got Davis into this fix to begin with. Business people passed by without pausing to look up. Shoppers scurried in and out of Macy’s and Saks Fifth Avenue across the street. Tourists and passersby sat on benches, enjoying another glorious day in the city.
Charles Duff, 24, a student at San Francisco State University, sat with his back to the rally. I asked him what he thought of the recall.
“Crazy,” he said. “It’s crazy.”
What’s crazy about it? I asked him.
“The idea that you can take out a guy and have all these people running to replace him.”
So you’re going to vote against the recall?
“When’s the election?” he asked before answering the question himself. “Tomorrow, isn’t it? I don’t know. I have to work. I have to work most of the day.”
Posted by dweintraub at 3:58 PM
If Davis is recalled, one of the major stories on Wednesday might be the number of people who fail to vote for a candidate on the replacement portion of the ballot. This number could approach 10 percent of the electorate, which, depending on the turnout, would be somewhere between 800,000 and 1.2 million voters. And most of them are likely to be Democrats who vote no on the recall and then skip Question 2.
The effect of this drop-off could be stunning. Suppose turnout is 60 percent, and the overall electorate matches conventional wisdom and comes in at about 43 percent Democrat and 38 percent Republican. I actually think it might be bigger and more balanced than that, but for the sake of this analysis, let's be conservative. Those numbers would produce about 9 million voters. About 3.9 million would be Democrats, and 3.4 million would be Republican. The remainder are independents or minor party voters.
But then suppose 10 percent of those voters skip Question 2, and 70 percent of those are Democrats, and 20 percent are Republicans. That means you lose 900,000 votes, and 630,000 are Democrats and 180,000 are Republicans.
The new electorate for Question 2 now looks like this: 3.3 million Democrats and 3.2 million Republicans, or virtually even. Such an adjusted electorate would be a highly favorable environment for any Republican, and certainly for Schwarzenegger in this race. If, as his campaign says, Schwarzenegger is weathering the groping stories just fine, this extra bump could drive his final numbers far higher than any polls have shown to date. And if, as the Democrats claim, the groping stories are undermining his campaign, the drop-off on Question 2 could be what saves him. Even if the drop-off is only 5 percent, it could play a very significant role in the outcome.
Finally, there is another form of drop-off that could also be large and would have a similar effect, compounding the one described above. It’s the number of voters who cast a “protest” vote on Question 2 for one of the 130-some also-rans on the ballot.
Posted by dweintraub at 7:11 AM
The Schwarzenegger campaign was circulating poll numbers Sunday from the California Correctional Peace Officers Association that showed the recall still winning big and Arnold far ahead in the replacement race. According to the campaign, the recall was leading 57-37 in the last four nights of the tracking poll, from Wednesday through Saturday. Schwarzenegger was leading the replacement race with 36 percent, followed by Bustamante at 21 and McClintock at 17.
But those numbers didn't tell the whole story. A source outside the campaign who is familiar with that poll tells me that the daily splits are more revealing. According to this source, support for the recall slipped each night, from 63-30 on Wednesday to 54-41 on Saturday. In the replacement race, meanwhile, the shake-up was less dramatic. On that question, Schwarzenegger began the period up 32-19 over Bustamante and ended it up 39-26. McClintock is pretty much remaining flat in the mid to high teens.
Remember, nightly tracking with small samples is dangerous on Friday and Saturday nights. But it looks like the trend some spotted in the Knight-Ridder/NBC poll is also evident here. The question is whether that slide on the recall issue has ended or continues through Tuesday's election.
Posted by dweintraub at 7:09 AM
This Mercury News story about the Knight-Ridder poll has some good insights about how this electorate might differ from any in the recent past, namely that Schwarzenegger is getting his margin from voters who have rarely gone to the polls.
Those voters, who are either newly registered or have voted in less than half of the previous six elections, tipped the Mercury News poll in favor of both yes on the recall and Schwarzenegger as the replacement.
Such new or infrequent voters probably view the allegations against Schwarzenegger as just another distasteful helping of traditional politics, Elway said.
UPDATE: Some analysts have noted that support for the recall dropped in the final two days of this poll's four-day run. That drop has been attributed to the stories about Schwarzenegger's treatment of women. But the poll also has an aberration: a sample on Friday night that was 40 percent Democrat and only 31 percent Republican. That compares to Wednesday, when the sample was 44D, 41R and Thursday, when it was 43D, 41R. Saturday it was 43D, 39R. Here is the day by day chart.
Posted by dweintraub at 9:07 PM
This Jill Stewart column published in the Los Angeles Daily News alleges that Gray Davis has a character problem of his own, a temper that rages out of control when things don't go his way.
Posted by dweintraub at 8:26 PM
The Schwarzenegger groping story is one of those interesting cases where neither side in a partisan political dispute wants to acknowledge something obvious: in this case that Schwarzenegger has more or less admitted that he is, or at least was, a serial groper. Asked about the allegations by ABC’s Peter Jennings aboard the campaign bus Saturday, Schwarzenegger said,
“It doesn't make any sense to go through details here with you. What is important is that I cannot remember what was happening 20 years ago and 15 years ago. But some of the things sound like me, and this is why I was the first one to come out and say, you know, some of the things could've happened. I want to apologize to the people if I offended anyone, because that not my intention."
I read that quote to say that Schwarzenegger is not going to get into commenting on every allegation that comes forward because he doesn’t remember where he was and what he did every moment for the past 30 years. But he’s also saying that “some of these things sound like me.” He has said he meant to be playful, now realizes he was wrong, and has apologized.
Reasonable people can differ on whether they think such an apology is sufficient and whether they think he really has changed. Every voter has to decide for himself or herself whether they think such behavior disqualifies him from being governor.
The problem is that Schwarzenegger supporters, for obvious reasons, don’t want to loudly promote the fact that he’s said he is guilty of these kinds of acts. And Schwarzenegger himself has clouded the issue by at times speaking clearly, as he did in the quote cited above, and at other times trying to deny some of the specific charges, probably in an ill-advised effort at damage control.
But Schwarzenegger’s opponents, surprisingly, also don’t want to bring too much attention to his admission, probably because to do so would also focus attention on the apology and his moments of honesty. They would rather focus on his denials and inconsistencies, which keep the story alive, keep the frenzy going and prevent voters from sitting back and reflecting on what they have heard and how significant they consider it to be in weighing their options in the recall and the race for governor.
Posted by dweintraub at 5:33 PM
Arnold Schwarzenegger plays guitar while Twisted Sister singer Dee Snider sings the campaign anthem, "We're not gonna take it." The rally at the state Capitol drew about 10,000 supporters and was a rainbow of ages, races and social status. No wonder the Democrats fear Schwarzenegger. Photo is from the Sacramento Bee.
Posted by dweintraub at 4:52 PM
The governor's cabinet, which rarely meets, is scheduled to convene Wednesday at 4 p.m., according to a source in the governor's office. They will be joined by all the other department directors at 4:45 p.m. In other news from the gov's inner sanctum, the New York Times reports that Davis aides have ordered storage boxes from the state archives and a list of approved vendors for shredding documents.
Posted by dweintraub at 3:57 PM
Secretary of State Kevin Shelley reports this morning that more than 3.1 million absentee ballots have been issued (3, 129,410). More than 2 million ballots have been cast- including absentee and early voting (2,010,020). This is about as many absentees as were cast in last year's election, counting several hundred thousand that were dropped off on Election Day.
Posted by dweintraub at 9:54 AM
I have just witnessed one of the strangest events I have ever seen on the political campaign trail.
It began shortly after the conclusion of Arnold Schwarzenegger's campaign rally in downtown Modesto. As the press was filing out, several reporters suddenly surrounded a woman standing in the pedestrian mall near the rally site. Only a few reporters could hear what she was saying. Soon the word spread: "She's looking for Arnold," one reporter told another, who told another. More reporters gathered around. Cameras and tape recorders were thrust toward her face.
The woman, with long brown hair, wore a bright red top, black Capri pants, and sandals, and she carried a canvas bag over her shoulder and a manila file in her hand. Schwarzenegger spokesman Rob Stutzman approached her and they began talking. Reporters crowded around closer to try to listen. The woman and Stutzman walked away, onto K Street, which had been shut to traffic for the rally. Reporters followed. Stutzman somehow broke free from the pack and guided the woman to a grassy area off the sidewalk. The pack of reporters held off at a respectful distance. It appeared as if the woman was showing Stutzman some documents from her manila file. Someone said there were pictures. Pictures of a child, or children. Before long, bystanders were shouting that the woman was the mother of a Schwarzenegger "love child."
It was now 3:30 p.m. It was time for the buses to depart. Schwarzenegger aides walked down the middle of the street announcing that the media buses were about to leave. At this news the reporters started to get edgy. The Italian correspondent started creeping toward Stutzman and the woman. Creeping closer. The reporter extended his mike. Sensing this, Stutzman turned around, trying to shoo away the intruders. The Italians then lunged past him and rushed the woman. "What did he do to you?" the correspondent asked. "Will you tell us what he did to you?"
Seeing the barrier breached, the rest of the reporters broke from their respectful distance and swarmed toward Stutzman and the woman. The two began walking back toward the rally site, pushing their way through the crowd of journalists. "Liar!" a Schwarzenegger supporter yelled. "Who paid you?"
The scrum moved slowly through the remnants of the rally. "Did you know Arnold Schwarzenegger?" one reporter shouted. "Were you sexually harrassed by Arnold Schwarzenegger?" another asked.
"The young lady is looking for her sister," Stutzman said flatly.
"What are you doing here?" another reporter asked.
"I am looking for my sister," the woman said. "When I find her we are going to leave."
Stutzman and the woman walked a block down the pedestrian mall, a couple dozen reporters in tow. Onlookers scrambled out of the way to avoid being trampled. "Watch the woman!" shouted the New York Times reporter as an elderly lady approached behind a metal walker.
Stutzman and the woman turned right at the corner. Then they walked about a hundred feet, turned around and walked back in the other direction, in the street, against traffic. They came upon a woman holding a small child. The woman in red, the other woman and the child got into a white Ford Escort wagon driven by a man. The car drove off. Reporters scribbled down the license plate number.
Stutzman walked back toward the media buses, reporters peppering him with questions. At an intersection he stopped, turned around and addressed the press.
"She was seeking to have a conversation with Arnold Schwarzenegger," Stutzman said. "I've talked to her. She has not made any type of accusation or charge."
Then he turned and walked away. The reporters boarded their buses, which then departed, about 20 minutes behind schedule, for the next rally in Pleasanton.
UPDATE: At a press availabiliy in Pleasanton later, Stutzman said the woman did not show him any pictures. She showed him a document, written in Spanish, which he could not translate. This item was updated at 7:57 p.m. to add a few more details to the narrative.
Posted by dweintraub at 3:56 PM
On the bulletin board in my office I keep a large white political button with black writing that reads: “I don’t believe the Los Angeles Times.” I bought it several years ago when I worked for that paper and saw the pin at a Republican Party convention. That sentiment, long descriptive of the Republican view of the media, has now become the mantra of the Arnold Schwarzenegger for Governor campaign.
With The Times having published two articles since Wednesday quoting nine women claiming that Schwarzenegger groped them or otherwise made unwanted physical advances, the campaign is trying to turn the newspaper stories to the candidate’s advantage by capitalizing on Republican voters’ distrust of the media.
There’s no other way to explain why Rob Stutzman, spokesmen for the campaign, spent 15 minutes this morning aboard the campaign bus (nicknamed Predator One) railing against the Times. The women’s stories in the latest article, he said, were untrue. He added that the paper gave the campaign only minutes to respond to the specific charges Friday night, and thus didn’t carry any reaction from the candidate in the first edition.
“It was irresponsible journalism. If you’re truly interested in the truth it’s unconscionable that you would not provide ample opportunity for response,” Stutzman said.
The campaign has suggested that The Times’ stories were planted by Democratic operatives if not the governor’s campaign itself. And while The Times has denied that the Davis operation was involved, the paper’s editor, John Carroll, was quoted Saturday saying his reporters would welcome tips about Schwarzenegger from anyone – including the governor.
Stutzman’s diatribe continued unabated as the media bus tooled from Fresno to Schwarzenegger’s morning rally at nearby P-R Farms. He ranted as the bus passed acres of half-built suburban homes, rolled by fields of plum trees and pulled up to the rally site. He went on so long on this theme that one television reporter on the bus interrupted him to ask: “Is this a declaration of war on the Los Angeles Times?”
Replied the spokesman: “What we have seen in the Los Angeles Times is unprecedented in attack journalism.
Another reporter asked: “The gloves are off, it sounds like?”
Stutzman: “We’re not going to sit back and let the Los Angeles Times practice gutter journalism.”
The extraordinarily bitter counterattack, while evidence that the campaign believes it can score points against the media, also suggests that the stories might be hurting Schwarzenegger. More evidence of that: Schwarzenegger’s wife, Maria Shriver, changed her schedule at the last minute to join Schwarzenegger on the rally stage Saturday.
“He is the only person who can bring us all together to make this state great again,” Shriver said. “He’s an extraordinary father, a remarkable husband and terrific human being…The man I love, the man I believe in.”
Schwarzenegger returned the gesture, calling Shriver “the greatest wife in the world, the most spectacular mother in the world. She has been an incredible partner.”
Then Schwarzenegger turned to the crowd. “Love this city. Love Fresno,” he said, forgetting for a moment that he was not in Fresno anymore but in nearby Clovis. “Love the people.”
Schwarzenegger did not address the groping charges directly, but he noted that he was warned that personal attacks would come if he ran for governor. “They have started,” he said.
“Davis,” he said, “knows how to run a dirty campaign. He doesn’t know how to run a state. That’s the problem we have.”
The crowd ate it up.
Later, back on his bus headed for Modesto, Schwarzenegger told reporters that he “was shocked” by the latest Times’ story quoting three women by name alleging that he had touched them improperly. Although he has admitted “behaving badly” on “rowdy movie sets” in the past, he said the latest charges were “absolutely wrong. They’re false.”
The Schwarzenegger camp insists that its internal polls show their candidate gaining strength since the groping charges first appeared. But en route to Modesto, reporters following the campaign started hearing by phone that Democrats were claiming overnight polls showed support for Schwarzenegger plummeting and the recall election's fate within the margin of error.
Then, upon arrival, the campaign distributed a piece published just minutes before on the website of the LA Weekly by reporter Bill Bradley. The article noted that peace activist Jodie Evans, who helped organize a press conference with one of Schwarzenegger’s accusers, has known and worked with Davis since their days in the Jerry Brown administration. But The Times, Bradley wrote, failed to point that out in its coverage today.
Bradley wrote his short piece on a Blackberry portable computer from aboard the bus and told campaign officials that it was coming. They quickly arranged to print it out at a Modesto copy shop and make copies for the entire press corps. As they were handing them out, the emcee revving up the crowd for Schwarzenegger asked the audience to welcome the media to town. With one exception:
“Who’s the guy with the LA Times?” the host asked. “Find him and beat him up, will you?”
Posted by dweintraub at 2:48 PM
All those GOP endorsments Arnold piled up last month didn't seem to be doing him much good at the time, and even prompted questions in this space about whether they might be counterproductive by raising McClintock's folk-hero profile. But now that Arnold is coming under fire as an alleged serial groper, the blessings from party pooh-bahs and fellow Republican pols are coming in very handy. Essentially, Arnold is the de facto Republican nominee, and not only are his backers rallying around him, the party is coming to his side. Early reports are that after the first round of allegations surfaced Thursday Schwarzenegger actually went up a bit in the tracking polls, largely on the strength of increasing support from Republicans. The same was evident at his rallies, where the crowds are growing and reporters are finding his supporters enraged at the media for, in their view, trying to tear him down. Not to say that more stories from more gropees in the days ahead couldn't turn that around. But on Day One Schwarzenegger seemed bouyed by his new-found friends in the Republican establishment.
Posted by dweintraub at 11:27 AM
Yet another sign of an unusual level of interest in the election, and a likely high turnout on Tuesday. The Los Angeles Times reports that interest in early voting on computer terminals set up around the county was very high. The story also notes that 1.6 million absentee ballots have already been returned statewide. Link via Rick Hasen's Election Law blog.
Posted by dweintraub at 9:12 PM
Newsweek's Karen Breslau posts a very readable, up-close and detailed account of the first day of Schwarzenegger's bus tour, which didn't exactly go according to plan.
Posted by dweintraub at 3:46 PM
The Pechanga Indians reported Thursday spending $1.8 million for an independent expenditure television campaign on behalf of Proposition 53, the measure to set aside a portion of future general fund growth for infrastructure. The 30-second ad includes a 3-second segment picturing Lt. Gov. Cruz Bustamante and noting that he is among those who endorsed the measure, after chairing a state infrastructure commission. Bizarre. The ad appears to be a genuine effort to help the initiative, which polls say is dead in the water, rather than just a sneaky maneuver to help Cruz's run for governor. Besides, if the intent was to help Cruz, the Indians needn't be stealth about it, since they already have kicked in a couple of mil on his behalf. But why spend that kind of money on a ballot measure that's so far behind in the polls? Do they know something we don't about the late turnout in this race, and how it might be influenced on an issue that so far has been lost in the shuffle?
Posted by dweintraub at 3:05 PM
Maria Shriver just completed a long speech to a women's group in Newport Beach, in which she extolled her husband's qualities but not directly address the charges leveled against him in the LA Times story on Thursday. "I didn’t want this campaign to end without being able to put my own two cents out there in the public about the man I know," she said. The speech was carried live on MSNBC, the sister cable network of Shriver's employer, NBC, but not on the other cable networks.
UPDATE: Sara Lee, a spokeswoman for Shriver, tells me that Maria referred to the recent spate of stories about her husband as "gutter journalism" in a press conference after her speech.
UPDATE 2: Full quote: "I think the voters are tired of gutter politics and gutter journalism."
Posted by dweintraub at 2:06 PM
Proponents of a referendum to block the state's new domestic partner law have been certified to begin collecting signatures, according to Secretary of State Shelley. They need to collect 373,816 signatures of registered voters by Dec. 21 to qualify for the March ballot.
Posted by dweintraub at 1:30 PM
The Secretary of State has published the final stats on who is registered to vote for Tuesday's election. Here is a link to the report. The Secretary of State's year to year numbers show a slight increase in registered voters from November 2002, to a record 15.4 million voters. Democratic registration has dropped nearly a full percentage point, from 44.6 percent to 43.7 percent, while Republicans have held nearly steady at 35.3 percent and declined-to-states have grown from 15.2 percent to 16 percent.
Separately, Republican analysts have surveyed the counties and provide more detail about what's changed since May, when the recall campaign began affecting the California political scene, and after tens of thousands of voters who had died or moved were purged from the rolls. According to this analysis, 465,000 new voters have registered since May, with 270,000 signing up in September alone.
You can find those numbers here: Download file
Posted by dweintraub at 1:16 PM
Arianna Huffington and MoveOn.org plan a press conference today to unveil television ads based on the LA Times story regarding Schwarzenegger's groping.
Posted by dweintraub at 6:27 AM
Here is the New York Times story on the Hitler quote. It includes the context, which is helpful.
Posted by dweintraub at 5:50 AM
The final Field Poll of the election is out this morning, and the numbers look bleak for Davis. The recall is leading 57-39 among likely voters, a sample Field describes as 43 percent Democrat and 38 percent Republican. Schwarzenegger has a big lead over Bustamante, 36-26, with McClintock at 16, and 22 percent undecided.
My favorite stat from deep in the poll is this: Among those who say they did not vote for Davis or Simon a year ago, or did not vote at all, the recall is leading 70-24. And this self-described group makes up 30 percent of the sample. This, I think, confirms the belief by many, including me, that much of the energy behind the recall stems from the unprecedented voter antipathy toward the selection they were asked to make a year ago.
--92 percent of Republicans and 54 percent of independents and minor party voters favor the recall, while 28 percent of Democrats are for it, up from 23 percent in early September.
--58 percent of men and 57 percent of women favor the recall.
--The recall is leading among all age groups except those 65 and over, who oppose it narrowly, with 45 percent in favor and 51 percent against.
--The recall is leading among all education levels except those with post-graduate studies under their belts.
--Regardless of their preference, 68 percent of likely voters think Davis will be recalled.
--If Davis were listed on the replacement ballot (sans Bustamante), he would get 30 percent of the vote, with Schwarzenegger in the lead at 36 percent and McClintock at 17. This is exactly the opposite of the theory posited by those who have called the recall “anti-Democratic” because the eventual winner in a multi-candidate race might get fewer votes than are cast against the recall (and in favor of keeping Davis). The Field Poll suggests that many voters who would not choose Davis in an election against other candidates are actually voting to keep him in office anyway, presumably because they simply don’t like the idea of a recall. In the recall, 57 percent vote against Davis; in the hypothetical match-up with other candidates, 70 percent vote against him.
--Bustamante gets just 40 percent of the Latino vote, with Schwarzenegger at 34 and McClintock at 6. Among Latinos, 20 percent are undecided or favor others.
--Schwarzenegger’s image has improved considerably since the debate. He now has a 52-41 approval rating, compared to 53-34 for McClintock and a disastrous 34-56 for Bustamante.
--Schwarzenegger is drawing 63 percent from Republicans and 16 percent from Democrats and is leading Bustamante 26-22 among independents and minor party voters, with 42 percent of that group still undecided.
--Schwarzenegger is leading big among men (41-26-14) but is also leading among women, 31-16-17, but 26 percent of women remain undecided.
Check for the complete poll here later this morning.
Posted by dweintraub at 5:15 AM
Priorities and Frivolities notes that Arnold also admired Napoleon.
Posted by dweintraub at 8:43 PM
ABC News drops the next bomb: unpublished outtakes from Pumping Iron in which Arnold allegedly says he admired certain parts of Hitler's rise to power and his ability to get the German population behind him.
Posted by dweintraub at 5:16 PM
I have emerged from the media bubble that is the Schwarzenegger bus tour, in part to try to get a sense of how the groping story is playing out here in the real world. The candidate did not repeat his apology at his second event of the day, in Orange County, but did mention the attacks indirectly, and his surrogates laid into the LA Times with ferocity. Their suggestion that the story was held until the last minute in order to damage Schwarzenegger still doesn’t ring true to me, because of what I know about how newspapers work and how stories like this evolve. But I do think questions about how The Times found these women, especially the anonymous ones, are a legitimate avenue for inquiry. If they were led to them by Democratic operatives or others linked to Davis, even if not linked directly to the campaign, that would be worth knowing.
The Schwarzenegger caravan is, of course, an extravaganza. More than 200 members of the media on four buses are trailing two buses carrying the candidate and his staff and supporters from San Diego to Sacramento. The trip was preceded by vague promises that reporters might be rotated into the lead bus for time with Schwarzenegger, but I am not sure if that is happening. I spent the first leg from San Diego to Orange County on Predator 3, as it was named, with about 44 other media types and three Schwarzenegger staffers. Almost all of those on my bus were television and radio reporters, and the scene quickly became an orgy of reporters interviewing reporters.
Entertainment Tonight interviewed several correspondents, including your blogger, for a piece that is to run tonight (though I pretty sure that my rather restrained reflections will end up on the cutting-room floor). I was also interviewed by an National Public Radio reporter while I was preparing to do a piece for MSNBC. The television hit was supposed to be live, with the picture feed sent via radio to a satellite truck driving alongside, which would then beam the images back to network headquarters in New York. Alas, the truck got separated from the bus and lost its connection, so my incredibly lucid comments were aired without benefit of live pictures of my standard journalist-issue black blazer and blue shirt. The logistics (and money) involved in this kind of stuff boggles the mind of this ink-stained wretch. The technology we were trying to use was first employed in Iraq during the war, then for Hurricane Isabel. From war to disaster to the California Recall.
Schwarzenegger, except for the apology, stuck to his regular stump speech, with the only surprise being the demolition of a car at the Orange County event to protest the recent increase in the car tax. The 1980s Buick was crushed by a wrecking ball dropped from a couple hundred feet above, where it had hung throughout his speech, suspended by a crane. The crowd roared.
I jumped ship in Orange County, hitched a ride to John Wayne Airport and am preparing to return to Sacramento for a day. I’ll be checking back with the Schwarzenegger gang on Saturday as they close in on the Capitol.
Posted by dweintraub at 2:24 PM
Arnold Schwarzenegger this morning denied the specific allegations in the LA Times story accusing him of groping six women but admitted that he had sometimes “behaved badly” on movie sets and apologized.
“Where there is smoke there is fire,” Schwarzenegger told supporters at a morning rally in San Diego. “I have behaved badly sometimes...I was on rowdy movie sets and have done things that were not right which I thought then was playful but now I recognize that I have offended people...I am deeply sorry about that and I apologize becaue this is not what I'm trying to do.”
He added: “As the governor, I will be a champion for the women... and I hope that you will give me the chance to prove that.”
How will this play politically? It was probably the best possible statement Schwarzenegger could make under the circumstances. He clearly is hoping to nip the story in the bud, to stop it before it explodes and overtakes the campaign in its final days. On television today and in the papers tomorrow, the stories will be that Schwarzenegger has apologized. That word will make some headlines. And so the dominant message will be not of Arnold groping women but of him apologizing for his behavior. Or at least those messages will be twinned. If opponents continue to pound him, as they will, he or his allies can say, look, Arnold has said he behaved badly, he has apologized, what else do you want? Some voters might even find his apology refreshing in this day of obfuscation and denial. The only gap in his strategy is that he is trying to have it both ways by denying the specific allegations in The Times while apologizing for other behavior not linked to specific women or actions. But I think that detail will get lost in the coverage.
Here is a full text of the apology from AP. I have added elipses and cleaned up a few words in my version above to reflect the exact wording.
Posted by dweintraub at 10:18 AM
I just saw a television ad against the recall featuring state Treasurer Phil Angelides. It was paid for by Angelides' own campaign committee, the one in which he has parked millions in anticipation of a run for governor in 2006.
Posted by dweintraub at 9:45 AM
The LA Times has dropped the hammer on Schwarzenegger, publishing a story in this morning's editions quoting six women -- four anonymously – saying the actor groped or touched them inappropriately in a sexual manner in separate incidents between 1975 and 2000. The campaign denies it. One of the women quoted by name was also identified in the 2001 Premier Magazine piece alleging similar conduct, and her story is refuted by a Schwarzenegger publicist who witnessed the incident. The other woman named in the piece is the former wife of a bodybuilder who has long feuded with Schwarzenegger and accused him during this campaign of uttering racial slurs. The four women who spoke without their names being used had told their stories to friends or relatives long before Schwarzenegger became a candidate for governor, The Times reported.
The story is authored by three reporters, including Robert Welkos, who is one of The Times’ most experienced investigators, and Gary Cohn, a veteran journalistic digger who won the Pulitzer Prize in 1998 for the Baltimore Sun and only recently joined the Times staff. The third writer, Carla Hall, is a longtime beat reporter who has covered parts of many campaigns.
The piece is credible, and disturbing. The disclosure of the incidents does not seem to have been orchestrated by an opponent’s campaign, although The Times does not describe in detail how it came upon the women other than to say they did not approach the newspaper on their own or through any of Schwarzenegger’s campaign rivals. Although none of the women involved ever filed a legal action against Schwarzenegger, the behavior described is abusive and crude.
Political fallout? Hard to say. If the story had been published sooner, it almost certainly would have had a major impact, and could have snowballed. But coming this close to the election, many if not most voters who never read the original piece might discount it as a political dirty trick. If all they hear is a television report quoting the Times piece and then quoting Schwarzenegger spokesmen denying it, the story is probably not a fatal blow. If one or more of the women go on television to tell their stories, it could become more serious.
I have already heard from people who question the timing, and the paper will be accused of dropping this at the end to try to hurt Schwarzenegger. First, I don't think that is why it ran today. The story is long, detailed and explosive. It was almost certainly edited at multiple levels and vetted by the Times' attorneys. Knowing the kind of bureaucracy that can be at work at a major newspaper, I suspect that the piece only now has cleared all those hurdles. Second, I think Schwarzenegger is helped as much as he is hurt by the timing. The campaign has prepared the world for the possibility of late chargtes of a personal nature. And he might be able to use the timing itself to try to fend off the allegations.
Posted by dweintraub at 9:30 AM
The LA Weekly's Bill Bradley, in an intriguing piece, reveals his version of top-secret negotiations in which he says he served as a go-between trying to negotiate a debate between Davis and Schwarzenegger. The piece raises interesting questions about the governor's strategy but also could serve as a future topic for journalism seminars: Is a reporter/columnist compromised by working with candidates behind the scenes on events that could have a major effect on the campaign?
Posted by dweintraub at 2:37 PM
Arnold Schwarzenegger just delivered a preview of his inauguration speech, or maybe his first “state of the state” address – to a few hundred supporters at Sacramento’s Memorial Auditorium, the site of Gov. Gray Davis’ first inaugural in 1999. Schwarzenegger’s speech, preceded by brief remarks by Senate Republican Leader Jim Brulte, former LA Mayor Dick Riordan, and businessman Bill Simon, laid out what he called his “agenda for governing.” It was a 10-point plan for the first 100 days of what he hopes will be a Schwarzenegger administration.
The first promise, borrowed from his good friend Tom McClintock, is to repeal the recent increase in the car tax on his first day in office. (He didn’t say whether he would do so before or after lunch.) Schwarzenegger, like McClintock, believes that he could do this administratively, since Davis hiked it that way, but you can expect somebody to challenge that in court.
Schwarzenegger also said he would freeze spending, though Davis says it’s already frozen, and call a special session of the Legislature to make spending cuts in the current fiscal year. He also wants to negotiate new compacts with the casino tribes – giving them more slot machines in exchange for $1 billion to $2 billion in revenue for the state. And he wants to renegotiate contracts with state employees. He mentioned the pension boosts those workers got in 1999 but didn’t pledge specifically to try to undo it. Other items on the list:
--A jobs package with “real” workers compensation reform.
--A budget proposal for the next fiscal year that closes the gap and restructures inherited debt.
--Streamline the education bureaucracy by consolidating nearly 100 special programs known as “categoricals.”
--Ask lawmakers to repeal SB 60, the bill that gives driver’s licenses to illegal immigrants, and take it to the ballot if they refuse.
--Pass a constitutional amendment to broaden public access to government records, and pass a measure to ban political fundraising while the budget is pending.
“We are ready to take office,” he said. “We are ready to act.”
But can he succeed? I think he can. Just as Schwarzenegger has rewritten the rules of political campaigning, if he wins, he will be able to re-write the rules of governing. He would do this because he would have an ability that the Legislature does not have and that most governors before him have not been able to master: the ability to communicate directly with the people of California.
I doubt he would get everything he wanted. I think he would be frustrated with the give and take required. But if the recall passes, the Legislature is going to see itself in the voters’ crosshairs and do everything it can to cooperate. John Burton, the Democratic baron of the Senate, is not going to turn the aged out of nursing homes. But he would deal with Arnold on anything short of his core values of protecting the poor and the infirm. And if the Legislature balks, Schwarzenegger could take his case to the people. How about a workers comp deal that raises benefits further for the truly injured while cutting lawyers and doctor mills out of the action? I think Schwarzenegger could get it passed by the voters. His toughest nut would be the budget, because he would have a big gap to fill and not enough time to make much progress on restructuring the way government does business. I still say he goes to the feds with other states for a package of immigration-cost relief. And for those who say Bush or the Republicans who control Congress won’t deal, remember that many of the states with high numbers of immigrants also happen to be the ones that are in play in the 2004 presidential election.
I wouldn’t expect Schwarzenegger to go back on his pledge and propose a tax increase. But I would not be shocked if, when he ran into Democratic opposition, he agreed to place a package of reforms before the people that included the Democrats' tax increase along with a permanent spending cap and other structural changes in government finance. I wouldn’t be surprised if, in repealing the car tax increase, he also proposed letting local voters reimpose it on a county-by-county basis, which would fulfill his pledge to give local governments new ways to raise money for their own priorities.
But I think the dominant theme of a Schwarzenegger Administration would be follow-through. Consider the seemingly small matter of education finance reform. Everyone in Sacramento knows that the special programs that riddle the education budget are a joke, decades of pet projects built upon special deals on top of obsolete ideas. The Sacramento Bee published an amazing series earlier this year documenting all of this. Davis promised to overhaul it. But when he ran into opposition, which was inevitable, he caved. Somehow I think Schwarzenegger would follow through where Davis backed down. It’s just a gut feeling I have. Maybe I’m completely wrong. But I think I’m right.
UPDATE: This link at the Bee includes audio of Schwarzenegger's address.
Posted by dweintraub at 1:43 PM
News flash: recall opponents are raising money for potential legal challenges after the election. In the Bee. Money quote in case you don't get to the end:
"I guess in California anything's possible," (Ted) Costa added. "We may have to send the guys with white coats in afterward and say, 'Hey, Governor, come with me.' "
Posted by dweintraub at 8:57 AM
Interest in the recall election is running at unheard of levels just about everywhere except, apparently, the online activist group MoveOn.org. Famous for helping launch Howard Dean into prominence with an online poll in the presidential campaign, MoveOn.org on Sept. 3 trained its sights on the recall and set a goal of getting 1 million California voters to pledge online to vote to keep Gray Davis in office. But four weeks later, according to the group’s website, only 262,000 people have taken the pledge. No problem. The group has adjusted and reduced its goal, saying it now wants “a team of at least 300,000 people working against the recall before election day.”
Posted by dweintraub at 8:17 AM
Schwarzenegger has scheduled an event for 11 am in Sacramento where he intends to "outline his governing agenda for the first 100 days of his administration."
Posted by dweintraub at 6:43 AM